Dugas & Circelli, PLLC
Insured's Position PaperCollege Hills Joint Venture v. State Farm Lloyds
CONFIDENTIAL · NOT TO BE SHARED
College Hills Joint Venture v. State Farm Lloyds · Second mediation · McArthur ADR

Separate the signal from the noise.

Insured's opening offer
$3,677,885.09
Loss location
2412 College Hills Boulevard, San Angelo, TX 76904
Date of loss
5/23/2024
Policy no.
93-G6-Z221-7
Counsel
Peter C. Salaverry, Esq., Dugas & Circelli, PLLC
State Farm estimate $65,660.49Drawn to scale
1.5–2.25"
Hail reported at the location
1,646
Patches State Farm prescribed
49,361 SF
Fully adhered TPO roof
30+ yrs
Premiums paid to State Farm

Letter to the mediator

Dana McArthur
McArthur ADR
5000 Quorum Drive, Suite 150
Dallas, TX 75254
November 20th, 2026
Sent via email: Dana@Mcarthuradr.com
CC to: Ashley@mcarthuradr.com
Re: College Hills Joint Venture v. State Farm Lloyds, Insured's Position Paper
Parties: College Hills Joint Venture, Plaintiff(s) v. State Farm Lloyds, Defendant(s)
Loss Location: 2412 College Hills Boulevard, San Angelo, TX 76904
Policy No.: 93-G6-Z221-7 · Date of Loss: 5/23/2024

Dana,

The Insured comes to this second mediation in good faith and with a willingness to compromise. We believe this matter is fundamentally a scope dispute.

As you will see in our mediation presentation, there is tremendous noise surrounding this claim, much of it generated by State Farm in its efforts to defend an indefensible position.

Beneath that noise are unmistakable signals: A questionable P.E.; an extraordinary patchwork repair recommendation, a paper-pushing adjuster defending the inexcusable, and an Insured with decades of loyalty to State Farm, treated as little more than a claim number. These signals are data points that, when viewed together, reveal a pattern someone with your experience will immediately recognize.

It is the Insured's hope that you can help State Farm separate the signal from the noise and focus on resolving the underlying scope dispute without overlooking the serious claims-handling liability that remains should this matter go unresolved.

Regards,
/s/ Peter C. Salaverry
Peter C. Salaverry, Esq.

Insured's opening offer

GC's Current Estimate$2,184,608.40
Deductibles Total($41,739.26)
Paid To-Date by Insurer($18,669.08)
Outstanding Benefits Due$2,124,200.06
Pre-Judgement Interest$600,159.26
Attorney's Fees @ 35%$953,525.76
Opening Demand$3,677,885.09
The Insured's opening offer to resolve this matter is $3,677,885.09.

The case

Tap a section to open it

After more than 50 years of building his business and caring for properties in his hometown, Jerry found himself in a position he never expected, fighting the very insurance company he had trusted for decades.

For State Farm, Insureds are reduced to two numbers: a policy number or a claim number. For those working at State Farm, the distinction makes little difference. At the end of the day, Insureds are simply another number in a file to manage. Reducing an Insured to a claim number creates distance, and distance makes it easier to forget that behind every claim is a real person whose life, business, and property are at stake.

This clinical approach to claims handling even extends to those who have faithfully paid premiums to State Farm for 30+ years. People like my client, Mr. Jerry Sefcik, the principal at College Hills Joint Venture. So, before we discuss engineering reports, repair estimates, and the millions of dollars separating the parties, I want to put a face on this matter. It is important for State Farm to see my client for who he is, because if we are forced to further litigate this matter, Jerry's story will resonate with a jury.

Meet Jerry Sefcik: Lifelong Resident of San Angelo, TX

Raised on a farm, Jerry graduated from Angelo State University in 1973 and began a career in real estate that has now spanned more than five decades. He built his business in the community he calls home, acquiring and managing commercial properties alongside longtime investment partners. College Hills Joint Venture, acquired in the early 1990s, reflects his philosophy of long-term ownership, responsible management, and taking care of the properties entrusted to him.

For decades, State Farm was part of that journey. Jerry insured his personal and commercial properties with the company, developed longstanding relationships with its agents, and even leased office space to State Farm agents, including at College Hills. It was a relationship built on decades of trust. Then came the devastating hailstorm of May 23, 2024. After more than 50 years of building his business and caring for properties in his hometown, Jerry found himself in a position he never expected, fighting the very insurance company he had trusted for decades.

This was not a cosmetic event. It was a high energy assault on a commercial building.

In the late afternoon of May 23rd, 2024, a violent storm with massive impact energy and widespread destruction tore through San Angelo, Texas, striking College Hills Joint Venture. Hail was reported between 1.5 to 2.25 inches at the location, with NOAA Reports of hail as large as 3.5 inches in the surrounding area.

Nine radar frames from 4:30 to 5:10 PM showing the hail core crossing the property
Radar frames, 4:30 to 5:10 PM. The star marks the property. Tap to enlarge.

The physical evidence tells the story. Heavy-gauge metal coping was deformed. HVAC panels were dented. The fully adhered TPO membrane sustained widespread tears, and destructive testing subsequently documented saturated insulation beneath the roof. This was not a cosmetic event. It was a high energy assault on a commercial building.

The Physics Matter: If hail carried sufficient energy to deform heavy-gauge metal, the integrity of the adjacent TPO membrane, and underlying roofing assembly, it demanded serious investigation. State Farm acknowledged hail damage. The failure was in how little damage it ultimately recognized.

What was received is a surface level investigation dressed in the authority of a professional engineering seal, and State Farm continued relying upon it.

P.E. Jaime Gallo was retained by State Farm through SDii Global, a third-party P.E. mill, that has built a reputation for doing cheap work for cheap prices by utilizing low quality professionals. State Farm is aware of SDii Global's reputation and still retained P.E. Jaime Gallo to investigate a substantial commercial hail loss. His cheap work report became the foundation for State Farm's determination of damages and prescribed repair methodology.

P.E. Gallo aka Side Hustler: Public records compiled by the Insured identify P.E. Gallo to have a wide array of employment activities. They include multiple outside engineering relationships, real estate ventures, and substantial house-flipping activities. His engineering work is largely clustered in third-party engineering firms. While there is nothing inherently improper about holding multiple professional positions, investing in real estate, or flipping houses, there is an issue as to whether P.E. Jaime Gallo devoted the time, attention, and technical expertise necessary to properly investigate this loss. The reality is he did not, and his low-quality work on this matter is evidence of this.

The Engineer Who Did the Bare Minimum: Despite obvious widespread hail impacts and torn roofing membrane, P.E. Jaime Gallo failed to perform the essential investigations necessary to evaluate the fully adhered roofing assembly:

  • No moisture mapping.
  • No core sampling.
  • No adhesion integrity testing.
  • No destructive verification of the subsurface conditions.

The Wrong Rubber Stamp: When confronted with extensive documentation such as drone imaging, thermal mapping, and aerial measurements, P.E. Jaime Gallo was completely dismissive of the additional evidence. Not only was he dismissive, but P.E. Jaime Gallo also issued a supplemental report containing references to an entirely different Florida property, incorrect claim-related information, and used his Florida engineering seal. Using the wrong stamp is not only a violation of law, but evinces his bare minimum approach to professional engineering. This was brought to State Farm's attention, and was dismissed with a no harm, no foul attitude.

The Contradiction: The Insured's GC subsequently performed the physical testing P.E. Jaime Gallo omitted, documenting saturated insulation beneath the membrane at tested locations. Gallo's report described the bare minimum of what he could see, and his conclusions reached far beyond. State Farm paid for an engineering opinion. What was received is a surface level investigation dressed in the authority of a professional engineering seal, and State Farm continued relying upon it.

Patches do not remove saturated insulation, restore compromised adhesion, or establish the integrity of the underlying roofing assembly.

49,361 SF · one mark per prescribed patch
1,646
Separate repair locations prescribed by State Farm's P.E.
New welded seam vs. the roof's own perimeter
Original roof perimeter1,584 LF
Seam added by 1,646 patches4,311 LF

The Mathematics: State Farm's own P.E. documented approximately one torn or fissured membrane for every 30 square feet of roofing. On a 49,361 square foot roof, this means approximately 1,646 tears.

State Farm's solution? 1,646 individual patches, an exceedingly deficient and inferior repair method. This means approximately 1,646 separate repair locations and an estimated 4,311 linear feet of additional field-welded seams across a fully adhered TPO system.

The Professional Reaction: Experienced commercial contractors and engineering professionals consulted by the Insured reported a remarkable observation: they have never encountered a repair recommendation of this magnitude.

The Insured's counsel has handled hundreds of property claims and has also never encountered a comparable proposal. Informal discussions with professional colleagues have produced the same reaction – This is not a conventional repair recommendation. It is an extraordinary departure from the selective repair approach ordinarily associated with isolated membrane damage.

The Patches Were Performed: State Farm will attempt to argue that because a roofer performed the patches, the repair methodology must have been appropriate. It was not. A roofer performed the work because State Farm directed the roofer to do so. When pressed on this subject, State Farm will try to hide behind the recommendation of its in name only P.E.

The net effect is a false recommendation, bearing an overused professional stamp, that allowed State Farm to prescribe what was little more than a grossly inadequate emergency repair. Performing this repair does not validate the repair. Patches do not remove saturated insulation, restore compromised adhesion, or establish the integrity of the underlying roofing assembly.

The Pre-Loss Condition Test: A legitimate repair must restore the covered property to the condition and performance required by the applicable policy and restoration standards. A patch city roof with unresolved saturated insulation and compromised adhesion is not equivalent to the original fully adhered assembly.

State Farm proposed a repair method that the Insured contends is exceedingly deficient, technically inferior, and incapable of restoring this roof system to its pre-loss condition. State Farm's burden of defending its recommendation rests on supportive evidence. So far, the investigation underlying it has not demonstrated that restoration is achievable.

Estimate 1: State Farm
$65,660.49

A narrow repair estimate built around 1,646 localized roofing repair patches and limited replacement of other damaged components.

Estimate 2: Insured's GC
$2,184,608.40

A comprehensive restoration estimate addressing the roofing assembly, insulation, HVAC, exterior stucco, commercial signage, equipment, labor, supervision, and associated construction requirements.

The Difference$2,118,947.91

This is fundamentally a scope dispute.

The difference between these two estimates cannot be explained as a simple disagreement over labor rates or material pricing. This is fundamentally a scope dispute. State Farm's estimate reflects a bare minimum investigation and thus a bare minimum scope. The Insured's estimate reflects a proper restoration scope identified through proper investigation and construction analysis.

The Insured purchased a promise of proper restoration, not a promise of restoration at historical prices.

The Insured's current estimate represents an increase over the estimate presented at the first mediation because it now reflects a more refined restoration scope and the use of current Xactimate pricing (TXSA8X_NOV26). As to the use of current pricing, the loss occurred more than two years ago, and because of the significant underpayment, the Insured property has been unable to be properly repaired, while commercial construction, material, equipment, and labor costs have continued to evolve. The Insured purchased a promise of proper restoration, not a promise of restoration at historical prices.

The updated estimate reflects the work and associated costs necessary to restore the property under current conditions. The issue is not whether every contractor line item is beyond dispute, but if State Farm's estimate captures the work reasonably necessary to restore the covered damage. State Farm cannot defend an incomplete scope merely by insisting its estimate is accurate.

Did anyone within State Farm stop and ask whether approximately 1,646 distinct patches could actually restore this commercial roof?

To the Insured this is a substantial commercial asset. To State Farm it is just another claim number. Consider the sequence. State Farm retained an engineer who documented widespread membrane damage but failed to investigate critical subsurface conditions. That engineer recommended localized repairs on a scale the Insured's experienced professionals say they have never encountered. Yet, State Farm repeatedly maintained that its estimate was complete, accurate, and appropriate.

The Question: How does a repair recommendation this extraordinary survive repeated opportunities for reconsideration? Was contrary evidence genuinely examined or was it processed as another item in an administrative claim file? Did anyone within State Farm stop and ask whether approximately 1,646 distinct patches could actually restore this commercial roof?

The Institutional Problem: State Farm's obligation to investigate does not end when an engineer submits a report. Nor does its responsibility disappear behind a professional seal. State Farm remains responsible for evaluating the evidence, considering new information, and determining whether its proposed resolution is reasonable. When an initial conclusion becomes effectively immune to reconsideration, the investigation risks becoming an exercise in defending a predetermined position rather than discovering the full extent of the loss.

The Claim Number Mentality: State Farm was presented with evidence challenging the foundation of its repair recommendation. The critical issue is what State Farm actually did with that evidence.

Oklahoma exposed the playbook. College Hills Joint Venture shows it in action.

The Oklahoma proceedings have exposed State Farm's internal initiatives, management directives, training materials, and claim-review procedures. Together, they reveal a coordinated approach to limiting roof replacements and controlling claim payments. The Oklahoma record validates what we are witnessing at College Hills Joint Venture: claims-handling techniques designed to systematically reduce insurance payments.

The Playbook Oklahoma Exposed:

  1. Restricting Roof Replacements: Management oversight and approval procedures designed to reduce full-roof replacements.
  2. Redefining Damage: Haag-based definitions narrowing what constitutes functional roof damage.
  3. Controlling the Conversation: Internal training, including The Art of the Conversation, directing how adjusters communicate and defend claim decisions.
  4. Institutionalizing Underpayment: Management reviews, adjuster training, and claim monitoring reinforcing restrictive claim evaluations.

The College Hills Joint Venture Connection: State Farm acknowledged widespread hail damage but prescribed approximately 1,646 individual membrane patches instead of replacing the compromised roofing assembly. Its retained P.E. failed to investigate critical subsurface conditions. The Insured supplied contrary physical evidence. State Farm nevertheless maintained its deficient repair position.

The Bottom Line: The Oklahoma record provides documented evidence of restrictive claims-handling practices, alongside allegations of intentional underpayment that remain contested.*

Oklahoma exposed the playbook. College Hills Joint Venture shows it in action.

* State Farm's recently announced $47.86 million settlement resolved the Oklahoma Insurance Department's regulatory proceeding, not the separate Attorney General action or private class-action litigation. The regulatory settlement is not a global resolution of the broader controversy.

Exhibits