McArthur ADR
5000 Quorum Drive, Suite 150
Dallas, TX 75254
Sent via email: Dana@Mcarthuradr.com
CC to: Ashley@mcarthuradr.com
Parties: College Hills Joint Venture, Plaintiff(s) v. State Farm Lloyds, Defendant(s)
Loss Location: 2412 College Hills Boulevard, San Angelo, TX 76904
Policy No.: 93-G6-Z221-7 · Date of Loss: 5/23/2024
Dana,
The Insured comes to this second mediation in good faith and with a willingness to compromise. We believe this matter is fundamentally a scope dispute.
As you will see in our mediation presentation, there is tremendous noise surrounding this claim, much of it generated by State Farm in its efforts to defend an indefensible position.
Beneath that noise are unmistakable signals: A questionable P.E.; an extraordinary patchwork repair recommendation, a paper-pushing adjuster defending the inexcusable, and an Insured with decades of loyalty to State Farm, treated as little more than a claim number. These signals are data points that, when viewed together, reveal a pattern someone with your experience will immediately recognize.
It is the Insured's hope that you can help State Farm separate the signal from the noise and focus on resolving the underlying scope dispute without overlooking the serious claims-handling liability that remains should this matter go unresolved.
/s/ Peter C. Salaverry
Peter C. Salaverry, Esq.

